| |
iMakeContent
|
||||
|
News
and comment by a journalist based
in London
Should euthanasia be allowed? This first appeared in Out There News, an AOL news channel, 10 December 1998. Ram
Kalbag, neurosurgeon: What
I find rather irritating is when people who oppose voluntary euthanasia
say that, ah, this is the start of the slippery road to fascism. What
they forget is that by making everyone conform to a single pattern that
they desire, they’re actually advocating the fascism that they claim
to oppose. I’m
just saying that we are living in a liberal society where each person
has freedom of choice. If I’m unconscious and unable to help myself,
I would not want any doctor who helps me to be charged with murder or
manslaughter. I'd want my medical attendants protected from what you
might call interference in the private and confidential doctor-patient
relationship. What
is interesting is that in the sixties and seventies, euthanasia was
carried out quite regularly for spina bifida in new born babies.
You can treat spina bifida. But often all you’re doing is postponing
their moment of death in the sense that you might do lots of repeated
operations and instead of dying in the first few weeks, they would die
when they were seven or eight and they had personalities of their own.
Professor
John Lorber, Professor of Paediatric Pathology at Sheffield, was well
known for this. He had what he called sub-caloric feeding – this
was in fact an euphemism for euthanasia. It was another way of saying:
we starve the baby. What
happens now, with antenatal screening, with ultra sound, is that a bad
case of spina bifida is identified early and the parents are offered
abortion. It’s up to the mother. And
that creates another medical dilemma. You see, modern medicine while
it solves one kind of problem, it often creates another. A mother who’s
expecting a happy event, on the basis of an ultrasound scan is faced
with a baby that’s very deformed and which may not live very long. She
and her partner have to decide whether to have an abortion. I’m
personally against abortion. This may seem paradoxical, but you
can’t ask an unborn baby. At least I can make a decision as an adult
who is fit and well that if certain things happen to me I don’t want
to be treated. Q:
What about people who are depressed? Oh
no. My view is that the choice must be made when you are perfectly fit
and healthy. One reason why I joined the euthanasia movement after I
retired was that I said this is what I want done to me. I made a choice,
a living will. If
something happens to me and when they treat me they find at the end
that I’m not as I want to be, that is I’m not independent, I’m incontinent,
unable to look after myself, I’d like them to quietly . . . shall
we say, see that I don’t know what’s going on. home|
article index | about
| contact
|
|||||